Skip to content
Accueil » ODALID’s news » Scanning a badge number or reading a card securely: the real difference in security

Scanning a badge number or reading a card securely: the real difference in security

  • by

Two badge readers may look alike but offer completely different levels of security. It all comes down to one simple question: Does the reader simply read the badge number, or does it read the card securely?

The serial number: convenient, but not secure

Every contactless badge has a serial number (the UID). Many access control systems simply read this number and compare it to a list. It’s simple, but this number isn’t protected by any secret (it’s the public ID): it can be read remotely and copied onto a blank card or a phone in a matter of seconds, using readily available equipment. A copied badge can then open the door just like the original.

Reading the Card: A Cryptographic Verification

Reading the card securely is a different matter. The reader and the card mutually authenticate each other using secret keys (for example, on a MIFARE Ultralight AES, DESFire EVX, or DESFire Duox card). A copy of the number is no longer enough: without the keys, it’s impossible to impersonate the card. It’s the difference between verifying a name written on a piece of paper and verifying an ID card.

Where are the keys?

The question remains: where are these keys stored? In a conventional reader, they are located in the reader head, which is mounted on the wall facing the street. In a transparent reader head, the reader holds no secrets: it simply relays the communication between the card and the central system, which alone performs the verification. This is Configuration Type No. 1 in the ANSSI-PA-72 guide, which is highly recommended. ODALID readers follow this architecture and comply with requirement D.2, level L2, of the guide: they can only be programmed by the central system, never from the outside.

Source : guide ANSSI-PA-72 v2.2 (2025), configuration type n°1 (§ 6.5.1) et annexe D.2 (p. 107).

How This Changes Things Depending on Your Industry

  • Access control and sensitive sites: A badge cannot be cloned, and a torn-out reader does not reveal any keys.
  • Public transportation: The same principle allows a door to be opened with a transit card (Calypso) or a bank card (EMV), while remaining within the ticket vendor’s secure environment.
  • Time and Attendance: A badge that cannot be copied means a time stamp that cannot be disputed.
  • Defense and Sovereignty: An end-to-end controlled chain, from the chip to the key, with electronics designed and manufactured in France.

What about your existing systems?